Compare Credit Cards
Rewards credit cards promise the world. Free flights, cash back, hotel stays, concert tickets. Most deliver disappointment. A few actually work.
Here’s what nobody tells you about rewards cards: the best one isn’t necessarily the one with the biggest welcome bonus or the flashiest perks. It’s the one that matches how you actually spend money. Not how you think you spend. Not how you want to spend. How you actually spend right now, today, in real life.
Let’s cut through the marketing and look at which Canadian rewards cards deliver real value. Some of these might surprise you.
American Express Cobalt: The Card That Shouldn’t Work But Does
The Amex Cobalt charges $12.99 monthly instead of an annual fee. That’s weird. It earns 5x points on food and drinks including groceries. That’s incredible. It works at maybe 80% of places you shop. That’s the catch.
But here’s why it tops our list anyway. Those 5x points on groceries and restaurants? That’s essentially 5% back if you transfer to Aeroplan or use them smart. Most families spend $800-1,200 monthly on food. That’s 4,000-6,000 points monthly just from eating. Add the 3x on streaming services (Netflix, Spotify, Disney+) and 2x on gas and transit, and you’re looking at serious rewards accumulation.
The welcome bonus structure is different too. Spend $750 monthly, get 1,250 bonus points. Do that for 12 months, that’s 15,000 extra points. Not a huge upfront splash but consistent value that rewards regular spending, not manufactured spending to hit some arbitrary threshold.
Front of the Line ticket access for concerts. Hotel Collection benefits. Purchase protection. All the standard Amex perks. But the real value is those multipliers on everyday spending categories that actually matter. $156 annually for a card that can easily generate $1,000+ in annual rewards? That math works.
Neo Mastercard: The Cashback Dark Horse
Neo came out of nowhere and built something different. Up to 15% cashback at partner stores on first purchases. 5% on groceries, 4% on recurring bills, 3% on gas, 1% on everything else with the World Elite version. Those are market-leading rates.
But here’s what makes Neo special: guaranteed approval on their secured card option. Building credit? Rebuilding credit? They’ll take you. Start with the basic card, graduate to the premium versions as your credit improves. Smart strategy for people banks won’t touch.
The partner network is key. Local businesses, national chains, online retailers. Shop there, earn extra. It’s like having dozens of mini bonus categories instead of the usual three or four. Plus they’re constantly adding partners so the value grows over time.
No foreign transaction fees on the World Elite. Mobile app that actually works. Instant cashback visibility. They built a modern credit card for people who live on their phones. Traditional banks should be worried.
Tangerine Money-Back and World Mastercards: Choose Your Own Adventure
Tangerine figured something out. Let people pick their own 2% cashback categories. Groceries, gas, restaurants, furniture, entertainment, recurring bills, drug stores, home improvement, hotels, public transport. Pick two (or three with a Tangerine savings account). Change them whenever your life changes.
Single person who eats out constantly? Restaurants and entertainment. New homeowner? Home improvement and furniture. Family with two cars? Gas and groceries. The flexibility is brilliant.
No annual fee on the Money-Back version. The World Mastercard adds mobile device insurance, rental car coverage, and Mastercard Travel Pass for lounge access, but requires $60,000 income. Both offer the same rewards structure. Pick based on your income and insurance needs.
1.95% balance transfer rate for six months. Useful if you’re consolidating debt while earning rewards. Most cards make you choose between rewards and debt management. Tangerine says why not both?
Scotia Momentum Visa Infinite: The Cashback Juggernaut
4% cashback on groceries and recurring bills. 2% on gas and transit. 1% on everything else. Simple, predictable, profitable. The Momentum Visa Infinite doesn’t try to be clever. It just delivers consistent value on the stuff you buy every month anyway.
The annual cashback payout happens in November. Just in time for holiday shopping. It’s forced savings that you forget about until a few hundred dollars appears on your statement. Psychologically brilliant.
$120 annual fee waived the first year. 10% cashback on everything for the first three months up to $2,000 spent. That’s $200 right there. Mobile device insurance up to $1,000. Trip cancellation coverage. Extended warranty. All the boring insurance that matters when things go wrong.
Income requirement is $60,000 individual or $100,000 household. That’s accessible for most established professionals or dual-income families. Not trying to be exclusive, just profitable.
Scotiabank Gold American Express: The Grocery Champion
6x Scene+ points at Sobeys, Safeway, FreshCo. 5x on restaurants and entertainment. 3x on gas and streaming. No foreign transaction fees. This card knows exactly who it’s for: families who shop at Empire-owned grocery stores.
If Sobeys is your main grocery store, this card is basically printing money. $1,000 monthly grocery spend equals 6,000 Scene+ points. That’s $60 toward travel. Every month. From groceries you’re buying anyway.
The no foreign transaction fee feature is huge. Most premium cards still charge 2.5% on foreign purchases. This doesn’t. Shop online from US retailers, travel abroad, whatever. You’re saving 2.5% automatically.
$120 annual fee waived first year. Up to 50,000 Scene+ points welcome bonus. That’s $500 in travel value. Comprehensive travel insurance. Purchase protection. Mobile device coverage. Amex offers for bonus rewards at specific merchants.
BMO CashBack Mastercard Family: Different Cards for Different Lives
BMO built a cashback ecosystem. Students BMO CashBack for people starting out. Regular CashBack for no-fee simplicity. CashBack World Elite for maximum earnings. Same bank, same app, different rewards structures.
The Students version is brilliant. No income requirement. 3% on groceries, 1% on recurring bills, 0.5% on everything else. Perfect for building credit while earning rewards on ramen and Netflix. Graduate, upgrade to the World Elite. Keep your credit history, improve your rewards.
World Elite version: 5% on groceries (first $500 monthly), 3% on gas and transit, 2% on recurring bills, 1% everything else. Roadside assistance included. That’s a $69 annual value right there. Flexible redemption starting at $1. No waiting for annual payouts.
Balance transfer option at competitive rates. Purchase protection. Extended warranty. All three versions integrate with BMO banking for fee waivers and bonus offers. It’s ecosystem lock-in done right.
The Wildcard Winners
American Express Aeroplan Reserve: For serious Aeroplan collectors. Massive welcome bonuses, accelerated earn rates, annual perks that offset the premium fee. But only if you’re all-in on Aeroplan.
Scotiabank Passport Visa Infinite: Six airport lounge passes annually. No foreign transaction fees. Scene+ points that transfer to travel easily. The complete travel package without being tied to one airline.
BMO AIR MILES World Elite: For the AIR MILES faithful. 3x at AIR MILES partners, 2x on groceries, 1x elsewhere. Shell fuel discounts. If you’re already collecting AIR MILES everywhere, this accelerates everything.
American Express Marriott Bonvoy: Hotel points that transfer to airlines. Free annual night certificate. Elite status boost. Only makes sense if you stay at Marriotts regularly.
How to Actually Choose the Right Rewards Card
Stop reading “best of” lists. Start analyzing your actual spending. Pull your last three months of statements. Categorize everything. Groceries, gas, restaurants, recurring bills, everything else. Real numbers, not estimates.
Now do math. Which card rewards your biggest spending categories best? Factor in annual fees, welcome bonuses, and insurance you’ll actually use. The winner usually becomes obvious.
Consider acceptance. Amex offers better rewards but isn’t accepted everywhere. Mastercard and Visa work everywhere but might earn less. Can you carry two cards? One for maximum rewards, one for backup?
Think about redemption. Cash back is simple but often lower value. Points are complex but can deliver outsized value if used right. Travel rewards are great if you travel. Terrible if you don’t. Match the reward type to your lifestyle.
The Rewards Card Strategy Nobody Talks About
Here’s the truth: one rewards card isn’t enough. The optimal strategy uses 2-3 cards for different purposes. Amex Cobalt for groceries and restaurants. Tangerine for your other top categories. A no-foreign-transaction-fee card for travel and online shopping.
Yes, it’s more complex. Yes, you need to remember which card to use when. But the rewards difference is substantial. We’re talking hundreds or thousands of extra dollars annually from the same spending.
Set up automatic payments so you never carry balances. Use apps to track rewards across cards. Set calendar reminders for annual fees and insurance renewals. Treat it like the financial optimization tool it is.
The Bottom Line on Canadian Rewards Cards
The best rewards credit card is the one that pays you the most for spending you’re already doing. Not aspirational spending. Not planned spending. Actual, real-world, happening-right-now spending.
For most Canadians, that’s the Amex Cobalt despite the acceptance limitations. For cashback simplicity, Scotia Momentum Visa Infinite or BMO World Elite. For flexibility, Tangerine’s customizable categories. For specific situations, the specialists like Scotiabank Gold Amex for Sobeys shoppers.
Don’t chase welcome bonuses if the ongoing rewards don’t match your spending. Don’t pay annual fees unless the benefits exceed the cost. Don’t complicate your life for marginal rewards improvements.
Pick the card that fits your life. Use it for everything it rewards well. Pay it off monthly. Collect your rewards. It’s not rocket science, but most people still get it wrong. Don’t be most people.
Why Choose Smarter Loans?
Access to Over 50 Lenders in One Place
Transparency in Rates & Terms
100% Free to Use
Apply Once & Get Multiple Offers
Save Time & Money
Expert Tips and Advice